Why Your Sales Pitch Sucks And What To Do About It
By Gabe Arnold ·
Yesterday I received a call from the gym where I work out every day. I didn’t recognize the number and I was on another call, so I let it go to voicemail. Once I listened to the voicemail, I realized that they were just trying to sell me one of their new membership packages, and I was glad I didn’t pick up.
This is a HUGE company with multiple locations and it’s sad that they have such a quality product, but such a poor sales approach. I like it there. I have no reason to name their company here, but I am going to tell you what they did wrong, how they could have gotten more money out of me, and even made me happier along the way.
I’m going to share three of their failures, and three important secrets that will make all the difference in your success when you are pitching new and existing customers.
To be honest, a lot of companies large and small have a sales pitch that sucks.
Why The Sales Pitch From My Gym Sucked:
1. The message was too long.
If you are going to leave a voicemail, that's fine. I’ve actually had great success with leaving voicemails while cold calling new and existing clients. It just needs to be short and peak their interest enough to get them to call back. You won’t close a deal with a voicemail.
2. The saleswoman called my son a SHE.
Now I don’t expect everyone to know what gender my son's name is. However, assuming one way or the other just made them look bad. They could have said “your child” or not said anything at all. Again, the message was too long and it sounded impersonal, so this didn’t help.
3. She immediately began with the price.
Starting with the price doesn’t always hurt, but not when you start with the price you want to sell the customer on.
How Do You Fix A Bad Pitch?
First off, don’t keep doing the same thing unless you are getting killer results. If you are closing more than 40 percent, you can stop reading this! You are wasting your time.
If you don’t feel like you’re getting the results you need, then I’m going to give you three secrets that you can apply to your pitch. With these three techniques, you’ll be able to be more confident, close more deals, and also make your customer feel good about their purchase.
1. Get your propaganda right!
I know that the word propaganda is usually associated with political or war time activities, but let’s reframe it here and imagine that you are about to deliver the absolute best solution out there for your prospective clients and existing customers. If you are really delivering a world class product or service, then more people need to know about it.
My gym just plopped a signboard in the hallway and then called me with a way-too-much information voicemail. That’s a failure in propaganda; a failure in marketing that then led to a failure in sales. Get your propaganda right by doing the following:
- “Leak” information out early and slowly. People love finding out about something before they’re supposed to, so give away the best perks of your new product or service to the people with the biggest mouth (or reach) and let them start the rumors for you.
- Ask your best customers and biggest fans to join a “Beta testing” group to try out your new products and services ahead of anyone else. This will help you work out the bugs in your product and will make them into your biggest champions.
- Before publishing prices, talk about the long term savings and benefits of the new products or service levels.


